AIMA

The Alternative Investment Management Association

Alternative Investment Management Association Representing the global hedge fund industry

You are:

Depositaries, quo vadis? Nowhere it seems!

Dr. Marina Grech, Associate

Ganado Advocates

Q4 2013

 

We are all aware of the four freedoms which characterise the European Union. We all agree that these constitute the fundamental pillars on which the internal market operates….. But is this really the case?

 

Decades after the establishment of the four freedoms, including the freedom to provide services throughout all European Member States, it appears that these rights are being undermined. What is even more astonishing is that the freedom to provide services is being restricted, or wilfully ignored, by those same European institutions that should be the guarantors thereof.

 

Originally, the Council and the Commission painstakingly ensured to render effective the freedom of the provision of services by credit institutions and investment firms. Indeed the Banking Directive was the first European legislative instrument which created the concept of a passport right for credit institutions on the basis of a harmonised authorisation regime. That is, in recognition of the fact that the different licensing requirements imposed on banks by each Member State of the European Union effectively constituted a barrier to entry, the Banking Directive sought to (i) harmonise the authorisation requirements for credit institutions in the European Union, and (ii) create a passport right for European credit institutions wishing to provide banking services in other European jurisdictions. In other words, a level playing field was created so that the licensing requirements applicable to credit institutions in any European jurisdiction would not result in a barrier to entry to the provision of banking and ancillary services in any other European Member State. Once national differences were ironed out, credit institutions could provide banking services in all European Member States, either by setting up a branch, or on a cross-border basis. The same passport right was granted by MIFID to investment services firms.

 

Interestingly, both the Banking Directive and MIFID regulate the provision of custody services. Whereas however, at present, the safekeeping of securities and the provision of safe custody services are principal activities subject to mutual recognition in terms of the Banking Directive, MIFID lists the provision of safekeeping services, including custodianship for financial instruments, as an ancillary service. This should change with the coming into force of MIFID II, which, provided that the current approach is retained, will ensure that the safekeeping and custody of financial instruments becomes licensable as a main activity.

 

The net effect of this is – or should be – that a credit institution or an investment firm, authorised by a European Member State in terms of the relevant directive to provide custody services, may provide these services in other European jurisdictions simply by exercising the passport rights granted by that same directive.

 

But is it really so? No. Notwithstanding these passport rights, based on the fundamental principle of freedom to provide services, AIFMD and UCITS IV provide that such funds may only appoint as custodians credit institutions or investment firms established in the home member state of the UCITS or the AIF.

 

It follows that a depositary for a UCITS or an AIF must have a physical presence in the jurisdiction where the fund is located. In other words, credit institutions or investment firms authorised in any European Member State in terms of the relative directive to provide custody services, may not exercise the passport rights granted by the directive regulating their activities, because another European directive regulating the operations of the fund itself precludes it.

 

At best this is a contradiction. At worse, it’s a clear disregard of the fundamental freedom characterising the European Union. The next question is obvious: is this difference in treatment justified?

 

The standard reply would typically be that this is justified in terms of investor protection. But is this really the case? Thinking about it from an investor protection perspective, what distinguishes an investor – retail or otherwise – who opens a managed account, from another investor who invests in a UCITS fund or an AIF? Nothing. In both circumstances, the manager must take into account the risk profile of the investor before making an investment for its client or allowing the investor to invest in the fund. Indeed, the only marked difference is in the obligations imposed on depositaries of funds, which are subject to more onerous obligations in terms of the relative directive. If anything, these obligations are a further safeguard of investors’ interest. 

 

From an investors’ interest perspective, one can argue that the possibility of having “depository platforms” or even a European centre of excellence for depositaries should lead to a reduction of operational costs and achieve economies of scale, thereby increasing competition. As a result, investors would benefit from reduced costs and greater quality of service.

 

Seen from this perspective, the ‘investor protection’ rationale does not hold water. It is therefore neither justified nor necessary to restrict one of the fundamental freedoms on such grounds.

 

The restrictive eligibility criteria for depositaries have given rise to a ‘depositary passport’ debate. The truth is that the depositary passport already exists. It is exercisable in terms of the Banking Directive and MIFID. UCITS VI and AIFMD II do not need to cater for it. The best interest of investors and the bolstering of competition in the internal market demand the cessation of such disproportionate and discriminatory treatment in respect of depositaries established in one jurisdiction and not in another. The failure to do so will result in a disproportionate monetary burden being suffered by investors in those Member States which do not have access to a myriad of depositaries.

 

mgrech@ganadoadvocates.com

www.ganadoadvocates.com

 

 

 

 

Back to Listing

Main Menu

  1. Home
  2. About
    1. Our Core Objectives
    2. AIMA's Policy Principles
    3. Meet the team
    4. AIMA Council
    5. Global Network
    6. Sponsoring Members
    7. Global Partners
    8. FAQs
    9. Opportunities at AIMA
  3. Join AIMA
    1. Benefits of Membership
    2. Membership Fees
    3. Application form
  4. Members
    1. AIMA Annual Reports
    2. AIMA Governance
    3. AIMA Logo
      1. Policy note
    4. AIMA Members' List
    5. AIMA Review of the Year
    6. Committees and Working Groups
    7. Weekly News
    8. Update Profile
  5. Investors
    1. AIMA Investor Services
    2. AIMA Members' List
    3. Investor Steering Committee
    4. Update Profile
  6. Regulation
    1. Asset Management Regulation
      1. EU Asset Management Regulation
        1. AIFMD
        2. European Capital Markets Regulation
        3. MiFID / MiFIR
        4. UCITS
        5. European Venture Capital Directive
        6. Shareholder Rights Directive
        7. European Long Term Investment Fund Regulation
        8. Loan Origination Funds
        9. Capital Raising
        10. AIFMD-Related Events
      2. US Hedge Fund Adviser Regulations
        1. Registration and Reporting
        2. Incentive-Based Compensation
        3. JOBS Act
      3. Asia Pacific Asset Management regulation
      4. Other Jurisdictions’ Asset Management Regulation
      5. Systemically Important Financial Institutions ('SIFIs')
      6. Remuneration
        1. UK
        2. United States
        3. CRD IV and CRR
        4. AIFMD
        5. MiFID
      7. Shadow Banking
      8. Volcker Rule
      9. Other
      10. Systemic Risk Reporting
      11. Dealing Commission
      12. Corporate Governance
      13. Securitisation
    2. Markets Regulation
      1. Bank/Capital Regulation
        1. Capital Requirements Directive
        2. EU Bank Structural Reforms
      2. Derivatives/Clearing
        1. EMIR
        2. MiFID II / MiFIR - Derivatives
        3. MAD / MAR
        4. Dodd-Frank Act Title VII
        5. Hong Kong
        6. IOSCO
        7. Singapore
      3. High Frequency Trading
        1. EU automated trading
          1. ESMA Guidelines
          2. Germany
          3. MiFID II / MiFIR - HFT
        2. US automated trading
          1. SEC Regulation SCI
          2. CFTC Automated Trading
        3. IOSCO
        4. Flash Crash
      4. Insurance Regulation
        1. Solvency II
      5. Market Abuse
        1. MAD / MAR
        2. Indices as Benchmarks
      6. Position Limits
        1. MiFID II - Commodities
        2. CFTC Position Limits
      7. Resolution of Financial Institutions
        1. Europe
          1. EU Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive
          2. EU Non-Bank Recovery and Resolution
        2. CPSS-IOSCO
        3. Financial Stability Board
        4. UK
        5. USA
      8. Shadow Banking
        1. International Shadow Banking
        2. EU Shadow Banking
      9. Short Selling
        1. EU Short Selling Regulation
        2. Hong Kong Short Selling Regulation
        3. US Short Selling Regulation
        4. Short Selling Bans
        5. Securities Settlement
      10. Trading
        1. Dodd-Frank Act
        2. MiFID Portal
    3. Tax Affairs
      1. Automatic Exchange of Information (AEOI)
        1. FATCA
        2. EU - AEFI
        3. OECD - Global Standard on AEFI
      2. Australia - Investment Manager Regime (IMR)
      3. Base Erosion - Profit Shifting (BEPS)
      4. FAIFs and FINROFs
      5. FIN 48 and IAS 12
      6. Financial Transaction Tax (FTT)
      7. UK Investment Management Exemption (IME)
      8. UK Offshore Funds Regime
      9. Other
    4. AIMA's Policy Principles
    5. Search
    6. Resources
      1. Guidance Notes
      2. Jurisdictional Guides
      3. Noticeboard
        1. AEOI: FATCA and other regimes
        2. AIFMD
        3. BEPS
        4. CFTC Registration and Exemptions
        5. Corporate Governance
        6. Dealing Commission
        7. Derivatives
        8. FTT
        9. High Frequency Trading
        10. MiFID / MiFIR
        11. Other Hot Asset Management Topics
        12. Other Hot Markets Topics
        13. Other Hot Tax Topics
        14. Position Limits
        15. Trading
        16. UCITS
        17. UK Partnership Tax Review
        18. US State and Local Taxes
        19. Volcker Rule
      4. Hedge Fund Manager Training
      5. Quarterly Regulatory Update
      6. Webinar Programme
      7. Regulatory Compliance Association
        1. About the Regulatory Compliance Association
        2. RCA Curricula and initiatives for alternative investment firms
        3. Meet the regulators and Sr. Fellows
  7. Education
    1. Research
      1. AIMA Research
      2. Industry research
      3. Search research documents
    2. "The Case for Hedge Funds"
      1. Global Hedge Fund Industry Paper: The value of our industry
      2. The Value of the Hedge Fund Industry to Investors, Markets and the Broader Economy: Research commissioned by AIMA and KPMG
      3. The Evolution of an Industry: KPMG/AIMA Global Hedge Fund Survey
      4. Contributing to Communities: A global review of charitable and philanthropic activities by the hedge fund industry
      5. Beyond 60-40: The evolving role of hedge funds in institutional investor portfolios
      6. The Cost of Compliance: Global hedge fund survey by AIMA, MFA and KPMG
      7. Capital Markets and Economic Growth: Long-term trends and policy challenges
      8. Apples and Apples: How to better understand hedge fund performance
      9. The Extra Mile: Partnerships between hedge funds and investors
      10. Key articles by AIMA on the case for hedge funds
    3. AIMA Journal
      1. Recent issues
      2. Search AIMA Journal articles
      3. AIMA Journal Archive
    4. AIMA Guides to Sound Practices
    5. AIMA guides for institutional investors
    6. CAIA Association pages
      1. Fundamentals of Alternative Investments
    7. Regulatory Compliance Association pages
      1. About the Regulatory Compliance Association
      2. RCA Curricula and initiatives for alternative investment firms
      3. Meet the regulators and Sr. Fellows
    8. Certified Investment Fund Director programme
    9. Services to Start-up Managers
    10. Useful Websites
    11. Glossary
  8. Events
    1. AIMA Events
    2. AIMA webinars
    3. Industry events
  9. Media
    1. Press Releases & Statements
    2. AIMA's blog
    3. Media Coverage
      1. Articles by AIMA
        1. Archive
      2. AIMA in the news
      3. Video interviews
      4. Industry news
    4. Media Contact
    5. Press Materials
    6. Photos of Jack Inglis