FCA consults on performance fee exemptions from workplace pension charge cap
Published: 19 November 2026
On 12 November, the FCA published proposals to exempt certain performance fees from the charge cap for default workplace pension schemes operated by FCA-regulated firms. The proposed exemption is accompanied by safeguards around transparency, valuation governance and fair allocation of fees.
The key features of the proposals include:
- Qualifying performance fees: Fees would qualify for the exemption from the charge cap if the relevant fees meet two conditions:
- They are fees calculated solely by reference to increases in investment performance, i.e. they are in substance performance fees. This would be a principles-based requirement so could capture a broad range of fee and remuneration structures (e.g. carried interest)
- A minimum set of pre-agreed contractual terms that address key considerations such as performance threshold, calculation period, payment arrangements, mitigation of short-term performance fluctuations and information provision.
- Information sharing and look-through: Eligibility would depend on a pre-agreed obligation to provide performance-fee information on request. The FCA proposals indicate that guidance would set out calculation methodologies, fee components and high-water marks, including underlying funds in fund-of-funds structures.
- Governance and disclosure: The proposals note that existing information-sharing obligations cover performance fees and that scrutiny of any arrangements is within Independent Governance Committees’ responsibilities. Additional guidance would support member disclosure.
- Commercial terms: the FCA proposals suggest that they will rely primarily on the Consumer Duty and existing obligations when assessing whether commercial terms are appropriate.
- Fair allocation between savers: Fee allocation policies should account for difference in how members contribute, join or leave. The proposals envisage schemes working with fund managers to achieve this outcome
- Valuation due diligence: The proposals envisage that providers must establish, on reasonable grounds, that appropriate valuation policies and procedures exist. If they cannot, they must not proceed with the investment. The FCA proposes setting out guidance covering governance, independence, conflicts, methodology and models, the role of auditors, frequency and third party oversight.
- Physical asset costs: The FCA is proposing to exempt physical asset costs for assets such as property and infrastructure from the charge cap for contract-based schemes, following a similar exemption on the trust-based side. Valuation costs would not be exempted and would remain capped.
The consultation closes on 14 January 2027. AIMA intends to submit a response and welcomes input from members. Please contact Erin Smith ([email protected]) if your firm would like to contribute.
